Dog Food Quality Score Calculator
How Good Is Your Dog Food?
Enter up to 3 main ingredients from your dog food label. We'll evaluate them based on expert nutrition standards.
When you open a bag of Beneful, you see cute pictures of happy dogs and bold claims like "Made with Real Chicken" or "Nutritionally Balanced." It’s cheap, it’s everywhere, and your dog seems to love it. But behind the packaging, there’s a lot of confusion. Is Beneful actually ok for dogs? Or are you feeding your pet something that could be hurting them over time?
What’s Really in Beneful Dog Food?
Beneful, made by Nestlé Purina, uses a mix of ingredients that raise red flags for many vets and pet nutritionists. The first ingredient is usually ground yellow corn - not meat. Corn is a cheap filler that gives dogs little nutritional value. It’s hard for dogs to digest, and it’s often linked to allergies and skin issues. Dogs are carnivores by biology. Their bodies are built to thrive on animal protein, not grain-heavy meals.The second or third ingredient is often chicken by-product meal. That’s not chicken meat. That’s the leftover parts after humans take the breast, thighs, and wings - beaks, feathers, feet, and organs. It’s not illegal, but it’s not high quality either. By-product meals vary wildly in nutrient content from batch to batch, making it hard to know what your dog is actually getting.
Beneful also contains artificial colors like Red 40 and Yellow 5. These dyes serve no purpose other than making the kibble look more appealing to humans. The FDA has never banned them in pet food, but studies link them to hyperactivity and behavioral issues in dogs. In fact, the European Union banned these same dyes in pet food back in 2010.
Another concern is propylene glycol. It’s used to keep wet food moist and prevent mold. While it’s approved by the FDA for use in dog food, it’s also used in antifreeze and is banned in cat food because it can damage red blood cells. Dogs tolerate it better than cats, but long-term exposure is still not well studied.
Has Beneful Been Linked to Dog Illnesses?
In 2015, a class-action lawsuit was filed against Nestlé Purina after hundreds of dog owners reported their pets getting sick after eating Beneful. Symptoms included vomiting, diarrhea, internal bleeding, liver failure, and even death. The lawsuit claimed the food contained toxins like mycotoxins - harmful mold byproducts - and that the company ignored warning signs.Purina denied all claims and said their products meet FDA safety standards. The lawsuit was dismissed in 2018 because the court found no scientific proof linking Beneful directly to the illnesses. But here’s the thing: absence of proof isn’t proof of absence. Thousands of dog owners still report similar stories. The FDA received over 1,000 complaints about Beneful between 2014 and 2017. Most were closed without action because they lacked lab testing results from the owners.
What’s missing is consistent, independent testing. Purina tests their own products. There’s no third-party oversight. So when they say a batch is safe, you’re trusting their word - not an outside lab.
What Do Veterinarians Say?
Most board-certified veterinary nutritionists won’t recommend Beneful. Dr. Lisa Pierson, a vet specializing in feline and canine nutrition, says: "Beneful is formulated for low cost, not optimal health. It’s fine for a short-term emergency, but not as a lifelong diet."Dr. Karen Becker, a holistic vet and author of "The Healthy Dog Handbook," calls Beneful a "low-grade commercial food." She points out that dogs fed on premium, whole-food diets live longer, have fewer vet visits, and show better energy and coat quality. She’s seen dogs with chronic skin infections and digestive issues improve dramatically after switching away from brands like Beneful.
Even the American Kennel Club’s official vet panel doesn’t list Beneful among recommended brands. They suggest looking for foods with named meat sources as the first ingredient - like "chicken" or "beef," not "meat meal" or "by-product meal."
Is Beneful Safe for Puppies or Senior Dogs?
Puppies need high-quality protein and fat to build muscle, bones, and brains. Beneful’s protein content is around 20-22%, which meets minimum AAFCO standards but is on the low end for growing dogs. The fat comes mostly from corn oil and animal fat - not the omega-3s from fish or flaxseed that support brain development.Senior dogs need fewer calories but more joint-supporting nutrients like glucosamine and antioxidants. Beneful’s senior formulas still rely on corn and by-products. They don’t add extra joint support beyond what’s in the base recipe. If your older dog has arthritis, kidney issues, or dental problems, Beneful won’t help - and might make things worse.
There’s no "safe age" for Beneful if you’re aiming for long-term health. It’s designed to be cheap, shelf-stable, and profitable - not to support a dog’s biological needs.
What Are Better Alternatives?
You don’t need to spend $100 a bag to feed your dog well. But you do need to look beyond the flashy packaging. Here’s what to look for instead:- First ingredient: A named meat - chicken, lamb, beef, or fish. Not "meat meal," not "by-products."
- No artificial colors or preservatives: Avoid BHA, BHT, ethoxyquin, and artificial dyes.
- Grain-free or whole grains: If it has grains, make sure they’re brown rice, oats, or barley - not corn or wheat.
- AAFCO statement: The bag should say the food meets AAFCO nutrient profiles for your dog’s life stage.
Some affordable, vet-recommended brands include:
- Blue Buffalo Life Protection: Uses real chicken as the first ingredient, no corn, wheat, or soy.
- Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Skin & Stomach: Still Purina, but this line uses salmon and rice, with added probiotics.
- Wellness Simple: Limited ingredients, no fillers, great for dogs with allergies.
- Canidae All Life Stages: High protein, real meat, no by-products.
Even store brands like Trader Joe’s or Walmart’s Pure Balance can be better than Beneful if they list chicken or beef as the first ingredient and avoid artificial additives.
What Should You Do If Your Dog Has Been Eating Beneful?
If your dog has been on Beneful for months or years and seems healthy - great. But don’t assume everything’s fine just because they’re not vomiting. Chronic low-grade inflammation from poor nutrition shows up slowly: dull coat, bad breath, ear infections, lethargy, or frequent skin scratching.Here’s what to do:
- Check your dog’s last vet visit. Did they mention allergies, digestive issues, or weight gain?
- Look at their stool. Is it soft, frequent, or light-colored? That’s a sign of poor digestion.
- Check their skin. Flaking, redness, or constant licking? Could be food-related.
- Switch slowly. Mix 25% new food with 75% Beneful for 3 days, then 50/50 for 3 days, then 75/25, then 100% new food. Going cold turkey can cause upset stomachs.
- Give it 6-8 weeks. Skin and energy improvements often take time.
Keep a journal. Note changes in energy, coat shine, bathroom habits, and behavior. You might be surprised how much better they feel.
Final Verdict: Is Beneful Ok for Dogs?
Technically, Beneful meets the minimum legal requirements to be sold as dog food. That doesn’t mean it’s good for your dog.It’s like feeding your kid sugary cereal every day because it’s fortified with vitamins. Sure, it has some nutrients. But it’s also full of empty carbs, artificial junk, and low-quality ingredients. Over time, it adds up.
If you’re on a tight budget, buy the cheapest high-quality food you can find - not the cheapest food on the shelf. A $25 bag of food that keeps your dog healthy for years is cheaper than a $10 bag that leads to vet bills for allergies, liver disease, or diabetes.
Beneful isn’t poison. But it’s not nutrition. It’s convenience disguised as care. And if you care about your dog’s long-term health, you owe them better.
Is Beneful dog food still being sold?
Yes, Beneful is still widely available in stores like Walmart, Target, and PetSmart. Nestlé Purina has not discontinued any lines, despite past lawsuits and consumer complaints. The brand continues to market itself as "balanced nutrition" with updated packaging, but the core ingredients have changed very little since 2015.
Can Beneful cause seizures in dogs?
There’s no direct scientific proof that Beneful causes seizures. But some owners report seizures occurring after switching to Beneful or worsening while on it. Seizures can be triggered by food sensitivities, toxins, or liver dysfunction - all of which can be linked to low-quality ingredients. If your dog has seizures, switching to a clean, whole-food diet is one of the first steps vets recommend.
What’s the difference between Beneful Healthy Weight and Beneful Original?
The main difference is calorie content. Healthy Weight has slightly less fat and more fiber to help with weight management. But both use the same base ingredients: corn, chicken by-product meal, and artificial colors. The "Healthy Weight" label is marketing, not a nutritional upgrade. Neither version is a high-quality food.
Are Beneful wet food and dry food equally bad?
Wet food has more moisture, which is good for hydration, but it still contains the same low-quality proteins and additives as the dry version. The wet food often has more propylene glycol and artificial thickeners. Neither is a healthy long-term choice. If you use wet food, choose brands with real meat as the first ingredient and no gums or carrageenan.
Can I mix Beneful with a better food?
You can mix them temporarily during a transition, but it defeats the purpose. Mixing low-quality food with high-quality food dilutes the benefits. If you’re switching for health reasons, go all in. Your dog’s digestive system will thank you.
If you’re unsure where to start, ask your vet for a list of affordable, vet-approved brands. Or visit a local pet store and talk to the staff - they often know which brands are actually fed by their own pets. Don’t let price be the only factor. Your dog’s health isn’t a budget line item - it’s a promise you made when you brought them home.